Alfa Romeo Tonale or Audi Q3: which is better?
Audi Q3 or Alfa Romeo Tonali: which is more elegant?
The Alfa Romeo Tonale and Audi Q3 are both incredibly stylish and attractive crossovers, but their design is one of the main areas that separates them.
The Q3 has a more conservative and simple design of the two models and uses clean, simple lines throughout the entire body.
Its large chrome grille is framed by headlight clusters that have integrated LED daytime running lights, making this car recognizable as an Audi product.
Regular and coupe-like Q3 Sportback models are available, but from the front, both have an upright shape that makes them appear slightly larger than they are, giving all versions of the Q3 plenty of road presence.
In comparison, the Alfa Romeo Tonale has a sportier, sleeker exterior, featuring a long hood typical of non-SUVs.
The signature left by the LED daytime running lights is even more distinctive, leaving those watching the Tonale in the rearview mirror in no doubt that there is a stylish car behind them.
What’s it like to drive an Audi Q3 vs. Tonale?
The Audi Q3 is known for its smooth, refined ride quality, and its suspension is clearly set up to soak up bumps around town.
It’s also a great long-distance ride, with efficient engines and a well-insulated cabin making for a comfortable ride.
The steering is precise and responsive, but it’s also light enough to make city maneuvers less difficult.
Sharing many mechanical bits with the Audi A3, it benefits from a range of efficient 1.5-litre and 2.0-litre petrol engines, as well as 1.6-litre and 2.0-litre diesel engines.
Newer Q3 models are also available with a 245-hp hybrid setup, which can cover just over 30 miles on electric power alone under the right conditions.
The Alfa Romeo Tonale, on the other hand, has a sportier and more dynamic driving experience, which all starts from behind the wheel.
The relatively small steering wheel is responsive and requires less input than some other cars, making it sharper and more engaging to drive on twisty country roads, though it’s still just as happy around town or on the motorway.
It rides a little firmer than an Audi Q3, but it still soaks up bumps and potholes well.
Power comes from a 1.5-litre mild-hybrid petrol engine that produces 160bhp and delivers top speed.
This is great because if you like to drive enthusiastically, you can do so without living in fear that you have hundreds of horsepower and that you will exceed the speed limit.
There’s also a 1.3-liter hybrid powertrain, which is also found in some Jeep models. With 280 horsepower, it’s good for a 0-62 mph time in a hot hatch that rivals 6.2 seconds, but should still be able to go 30 to 40 miles without its engine with pinpoint acceleration.
The Tonale PHEV as well as many versions of the Audi Q3 come with all-wheel drive for added stability in slippery conditions, but lower-spec models are front-wheel drive as standard, which helps save fuel.
Comparison between the Audi Q3 and the Alfa Romeo Tonali from the inside
The Audi Q3 offers a modern, high-tech interior that’s packed with features but still manages to have a minimalist design.
It has a great infotainment system that controls many of the car’s functions and a secondary screen in the form of a digital instrument cluster.
Depending on which version you choose, you can expect the latest in-car technology such as wireless phone charging and a high-end sound system.
The popular S line models get sporty styling inside and out as well as bright LED headlights and leather upholstery, but the truth is that even the entry-level Sport versions get parking sensors, cruise control and much more.
The Alfa Romeo’s interior isn’t as advanced as the Audi’s – it has a smaller touchscreen and more of the car’s controls are modified using physical controls.
You get the brand’s famous “DNA” drive mode select features, which allow drivers to choose between sportier and more natural driving modes.
Alfa Romeo Tonale and Audi Q3 dimensions and trunk space
With a length of 4,483 mm, the Audi Q3 is slightly longer than the A3 hatchback. It is 2,024 mm wide, including mirrors, and 1,616 mm high.
Despite its less bulky appearance, the Tonale has more space, measuring 4,528 mm long and 2,082 mm wide, including mirrors.
However, it is shorter (1601-1614mm depending on specifications), which helps give it a sporty appearance.
There’s not much that separates these two numbers in terms of practicality, and the difference between these numbers becomes less clear in the real world.
The Q3 has a 530-litre boot, which expands to 1,525 liters with the rear seats folded. The Tonale has a slightly smaller 500-litre boot, but slightly more space at 1,550 liters overall.
The plug-in hybrid variants each have less space to accommodate the batteries – they measure 380/1375 liters (Audi Q3) and 385/1430 liters (Alfa Romeo Tonale).
Alfa Romeo Tonale vs Audi Q3 for sale: which is more reliable?
When it comes to reliability, Audi has a better reputation than Alfa Romeo historically, although the gap is closing quickly.
This is because Audi has been part of the Volkswagen Group for many decades, so it benefits from tried and tested technologies from brands such as Volkswagen, Seat and Skoda.
Alfa Romeo, which is part of the same group as Jeep, was recently acquired by Stellantis, the same company that now owns Citroen, Peugeot, Vauxhall and others, which has helped improve its reputation.
Used Audi Q3 vs. Used Alfa Romeo Tonale: Which Should I Buy?
Since the Audi Q3 and Alfa Romeo Tonale are the same size inside and out, the main factor behind your decision should be what you like more.
Buy an Audi if you value an upscale, premium interior with plenty of automotive technology, but consider an Alfa Romeo if you want a less expensive, fun-to-drive option.